Record Label Challenges AI-Generated Song Allegedly Mimicking Jorja Smith
Jorja Smith’s record label, FAMM, has raised concerns about a track titled “I Run,” which they claim uses artificial intelligence to replicate her voice.
Song Details and Removal
The track, released by British dance group Haven, features vocals from an uncredited female singer. Observers have noted similarities to Smith’s voice. The song gained popularity on TikTok in October and was poised to chart in the US and UK. However, it was removed from streaming services due to allegations of copyright infringement and artist impersonation.
Record Label’s Response
FAMM is pursuing compensation, alleging that “I Run” was created using AI trained on Smith’s music. Despite Haven releasing a version with new vocals, the label maintains that both versions infringe on Smith’s rights and exploit the efforts of her collaborators, as noted by the BBC.
FAMM stated on Instagram, “This issue extends beyond Jorja. We cannot let this become standard practice.” They emphasized their responsibility to address the growing influence of AI in the music industry, which is rapidly advancing beyond regulation.
AI’s Role and Industry Impact
The label advocates for clear labeling of AI-generated content, allowing consumers to make informed choices. They also seek to allocate any compensation awarded from “I Run” to Smith’s co-writers, proportional to their contributions to her catalog, should AI involvement be confirmed.
Creators of “I Run” admitted to using AI, with the original vocals provided by producer and songwriter Harrison Walker. Another producer, Jacob Donaghue (Waypoint), stated that AI software Suno was employed to modify the vocals.
According to Billboard, Walker and Donaghue confirmed their involvement in writing and producing the song, acknowledging the use of AI to transform the vocals.
The BBC reported that Suno’s spokesperson admitted the software was trained on copyrighted material, claiming it was lawful under “fair use” provisions. It remains unclear if Smith’s music was part of this training.
Broader Context and Industry Reactions
AI’s role in music has sparked debate, with many artists expressing concerns. Earlier this year, prominent musicians like Kate Bush and Paul McCartney released a silent album to protest AI’s impact on copyright laws.
In May, several artists, including McCartney and Elton John, petitioned for stronger protections against AI infringement. Spotify recently removed millions of AI-generated tracks, highlighting ongoing industry challenges.
AI-generated acts like The Velvet Sundown and Xania Monet have also made headlines, underscoring the evolving landscape of music creation.
